When the writter wrote the book he
has to accept the criticism. The important part is that people are the main
critics of the work because they read it and make own opinion sometimes they
are more or less relevant. On the other hand we have a special critics and they
can make an opinion of people depend on what they wrote about the book. In past
the main critics were ruler or the church they can prohobited the book bec ause
they just do not like it. Luckily is not Shakespeares case. It is hard to find some relevant criticism about
the Shakespeare because he lived far away and todays critics do not really know
the conditions when he was writing. But they can estimate it and wrote it but
it is also hard when the writter is dead and can not response it.
I found many criticisms… but they are not
really critical but a bit more editing or describing diferences atc. Mr. Bonnard´s words about the A Midsummer
Night's Dream: the main thesis is that two totally different worlds, the
fantasy full of nymphs and goods and the normal worldry life mentioned in this
play exist diverse from each other and those two worlds never meet and put together in one world. The
critics shows that inhabitant the fantasy world are really ethereal and
mystical creatures in the meaning that they are missing the real feeling and
intellingence. But this world is not less important then the normal, Bonnard
argues that the mystical world influence the whole area of normal life. Although
they are different in many things and they never meet each other they influence each other without knowing of
the other world. In Mr. Bonnards words „The
inhabitants of the fairy world, the critic explains, are indeed ethereal in the
sense that they lack true feelings and intelligence.“ He means that they are not dangerous but they
do not have real feeling as our main characters, they do not have real problems
they have their own world. They do not think about the consequences for example
when the servant of the good use the flower to make Helena happier and fell in
love with Demetrius. „And yonder shines Aurora's harbinger. At whose approach,
ghosts, wandering here and there.Troop home to churchyards.“ This quote told Puck to the Oberon that his
work about the lovers Hermie, Lysander and Helena, Demetrie it is almost done.
This express that the mystics world everything see on easy way there is not
problem. Means they they do not have everyday problems like people and it
support the quote from Bonnards critics that the fairy world have a lack of
true feeling and inteligence. In many stories with a fairy world we can find that the person do not have real view on the world everything it is easy for them, they use the magic stick and everything what you want it is possible.
In conclusion Mr. Bonnards critics is truly true. He has a good describing of fairy person and in context of the book they are really lack true feelings and inteligence but they are necessary for the normal world. They are so much different but influence each other too much to condemn the mystical one.
Žádné komentáře:
Okomentovat